1) The O.C., because that show was seriously brilliant (if you ignore Marissa, who is the worst).
2) Gilmore Girls, because I'm kind of dying without an infusion of Lorelai-Gilmore-fast-talk and Rory-Gilmore-earnestness. And Jess. Always Jess. But there's too many seasons to own/get on disc rental, so help a girl out, okay Netflix?
3) Chuck, because that show is ADORABLE.
4) Lois and Clark, the New Adventures of Superman, because mid-90s Dean Cain.
5) Semi off topic, but seriously, netflix, stop putting shows that have been on Instant for OVER A YEAR in the "new arrivals" section, because now you're just lying.